Notes
Outline
Empowering Internet
Optimizing Internet
In Mongolia
Issue is Performance
The Internet is a great tool
If the tool doesn’t work well, we must fix the tool or replace it
The evolution of inter-networks turns back to the local environment
The intent is to create a utility meeting the needs of Mongolia’s entire community
Government
Business
Education
Society
Entertainment
Internet Performance Evolution
Starts with basic connectivity
One or more networks connect to the Internet
Mongolia ISPs pay all
International leased capacity
Ports on Tier ½ routers
Volume sensitive billing
The more successful you are – the faster you run into financial difficulty
Connectivity Model - Today
Problems Occur
Additional Concerns
Mongolia –to- Mongolia traffic
Two satellite hops (1200ms +)
Congestion on inbound links
Local traffic dropped outside of Mongolia
Intra-Mongolia performance Unacceptable
Cost of higher capacity ports at Tier ½
Cost of capacity on international links
User Community Responds
Hosting local content in US/Intl
Reluctant to build business process into Internet environment
The Result
Mongolia Internet community does not have rapid organic growth
Revenue leaves Mongolia for international hosting providers
Advanced models of Internet based business and community growth delayed
Business to Consumer
Business to Business
Government to Business/Consumer
Alternate Model
Benefits to Mongolia
National Internet traffic stays local
ISPs do not pay Tier 1/2 to carry Mongolian originating and terminating traffic
Businesses with primary Mongolia target markets do not need to host their content outside of Mongolia
B2B and supply chains can emerge when economy and market is ready
What Mongolia Can Do Better
National content cache
All ISPs have access to the same routes
Bandwidth costs can turn back into local business and value added service
Obvious need to address competitive considerations and content ownership questions
Next Steps
Confirm facility location, management, and prepare location to implement M-IX
Receive equipment
Routers on order
Additional servers when needed by implementation plan
Modems on order
Arrange local access lines for M-IX
Determine if ISP community has any considerations on design, location, operation, features, or implementation of the M-IX
Actual design plan, as it is, should be available via the M-IX website
http://www.pacific-tier.com/mix/mix.htm
Agree on membership terms
Membership criteria
Membership dues/costs
M-IX infrastructure cost recovery
Service level agreements
Recommendation for M-IX
Possible Options
ISP Provided Access The ISP connects their equipment directly onto the IX switch via 100BaseT Fast Ethernet. ISP will provide all equipment and connectivity.  ISP is colocated with M-IX (ISP A)
Dedicated IX Switch Access: The ISP connects their equipment onto the IX switch via an SDSL/HDSL/ATM circuit at 10/100BaseT. The ISP router should have a 10/100BaseT Ethernet Port to terminate traffic from the IX. (ISP B)
Dedicated IX Router Access: The ISP connects their equipment over a dedicated circuit onto a MIX managed router. The ISP router should have a high speed V.35 serial port available for connecting to the CSU/DSU provided by the telco. (ISP B)
Managed IX Access: MIX will provide a router on both sides of the dedicated circuit to provide managed IX access. The ISP should have an available Ethernet port and IP address on their Network. (ISP C)
Routing Options
Dynamic Routing.  Dynamic Routing Protocols allows the network to automatically re-route during network outages, and is strongly recommended for IX route exchanges.
BGPv4 is the de-facto inter-domain routing protocol used by ISPs around the world. BGP allows advanced route filtering capabilities that can protect the ISP network stability that is not available with other traditional IGP routing protocols, such as RIP and OSPF.
As MIX has not been assigned an official Autonomous System Number (ASN), we will use the IANA assigned private network ASN (AS 65001-65535). IX participants may peer directly with each other to exchange routes, but is recommended to peer with the MIX router to receive routes from participants not using BGP.
As most ISPs in Mongolia do not currently have the software and hardware required for BGP peering, RIPv2 has been selected as an alternative mechanism to exchange routing information on the IX. Routes learned from the IX should be redistributed into the ISP’s IGP.
Static Routing.  IX participants may choose to use static routing, although this may cause a “black hole” during network outages.
Security
Route Announcements
MIX will only accept and redistribute registered routes from member ISPs
Member ISPs are strongly recommended to install an inbound filter list on their router to ensure false routing information is not inserted into their routing tables
Customers are also strongly advised to install an outbound filter list, so they do not announce the IX routes to the Internet, or Internet routes to the IX, particularly if they are using a dynamic routing protocol to their upstream provider
Packet Filtering
MIX should not filter traffic between MIX participants
If MIX participants are concerned about other participants using their network as the default gateway to the Internet, they are recommended to install a filter list on their IX interface to restrict traffic
If the M-IX is Successful…
Performance increase for Mongolia-Mongolia traffic should get much better
Performance on non-Mongolia traffic should show a modest improvement
The next generation of network integration into B2B, B2C, education, and government will have a better chance to emerge and grow